Custom vs. Off-the-Shelf Training: Which eLearning Solution Shines?

Maximizing Learning Impact Through Tailored Solutions

In today’s corporate landscape, where effective training strategies are paramount, organizations face a critical choice: Should they invest in custom training solutions or stick with off-the-shelf (OTS) content? While both methods have their strengths, customized training stands out as it fosters personalized learning experiences, allowing learners to progress from basic knowledge to advanced skills through interactive elements like gamification and immersive technologies such as AR/VR.

The Case for Custom Training: A Superior Approach

Custom training solutions yield remarkable results by aligning with an organization’s unique objectives, culture, and specific challenges. Unlike generic courses that offer a one-size-fits-all approach, custom training harnesses personalized learning techniques to drive deeper engagement, tailored outcomes, and measurable successes. The underlying hypothesis is straightforward: Custom training creates transformative learning journeys, enhancing knowledge application and synthesis while ensuring a greater return on investment (ROI).

Value Across the Learning Spectrum

Custom training delivers distinct advantages throughout each stage of the learning journey.

1. Knowledge Level: Laying the Groundwork

• Offers precise, role-specific information that meets learners’ needs.
• Incorporates organizational branding and policies for enhanced relevance.

2. Understanding Level: Building Connections

• Provides adaptable learning paths to ensure comprehension within operational contexts.
• Encourages critical thinking through scenario-based learning.

3. Application Level: Practical Implementation

• Employs simulations and hands-on exercises for learners to practice their skills in realistic scenarios.
• Strengthens problem-solving capabilities through interactive assessments.

4. Synthesis Level: Driving Innovation

• Utilizes advanced technologies like AR/VR to create immersive learning environments that foster innovation.
• Incorporates tools such as gamified simulations and 3D assessments for enhanced engagement.

Compelling Evidence for Custom Solutions

• Personalized learning can boost retention rates by up to 60%, making training more actionable (Association for Talent Development, 2019).
• Immersive approaches, like VR simulations, result in 42% greater engagement compared to conventional training formats (LinkedIn Learning Report, 2022).
• Role-specific training modules yield 30% higher competency improvements than off-the-shelf courses (McKinsey, 2022).

Development Process of Custom Training

The creation of custom training programs typically adheres to a systematic approach, often based on the ADDIE model (Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, and Evaluation).

The initial phase starts with a comprehensive analysis of the organization’s training requirements, encompassing identification of skill gaps, specific demands, and areas needing improvement. This data collection occurs through surveys, interviews, performance assessments, and discussions with stakeholders.

Following the analysis, clear and measurable learning objectives are established, aligning with the organization’s strategic goals.

A training blueprint is then crafted, outlining the format and logistical considerations including timelines, team size, and complexity level.

Next, the actual training materials are developed, employing the defined learning objectives and selecting appropriate technologies, such as a Learning Management System, video content, or social platforms.

The deployment phase involves delivering the training course as well as preparing learner support personnel and conducting assessments.

The concluding step involves evaluating the program’s effectiveness through participant feedback and post-training assessments to gauge its impact.

Custom vs. Off-The-Shelf Training: A Comparative Overview

When to Opt for Custom Training

Custom solutions excel for organizations that require tailored, impactful learning approaches:

1. Addressing Unique Training Needs: For industries with specialized workflows that mandate detailed training aligned with organizational procedures.
   Example: ERP training modules reflective of internal systems.
2. Reflecting Organizational Identity: Internal training materials mirroring brand values and success stories facilitate engagement and cultural alignment.
   Example: Onboarding modules that showcase company values in real workplace contexts.
3. Fostering Synthesis-Level Learning: Custom modules leveraging immersive methods like AR/VR or gamification enhance higher-level skills such as innovation and decision-making.
   Example: VR safety training that reduced workplace incidents by 30%.

Success Stories: Custom Training in Action

• Healthcare Training: A VR simulation enhanced nurses’ emergency procedures, improving response times by 30%.
• Manufacturing Upskilling: AR training modules equipped technicians on complex machinery, resulting in a 20% reduction in downtime.
• Retail Onboarding: Gamified learning paths boosted new-hire retention by 25%, incorporating company branding and service standards.

Use Case Example

ABC Solutions, a rapidly expanding SaaS provider with over 500 employees, rolled out a new CRM platform to streamline sales and marketing channels. Initially leaning towards a popular off-the-shelf CRM training program, they found it lacked context for ABC’s unique sales cycles and workflows.

Following the off-the-shelf training, a notable 15% drop in sales productivity occurred within the first month, coupled with a 40% spike in CRM-related queries. Frustration was rampant among the sales team, highlighted by a 25% dissatisfaction rate in an internal survey regarding the training’s relevance.

In response, ABC leadership sought a custom training solution. Partnering with a Learning and Development firm, they created a training program tailored to their CRM setup:

• Role-Specific Modules: Training paths designed for specific roles focused on pertinent features and functionalities.
• Scenario-Based Learning: Real-life scenarios based on previous deals and challenges.
• Internal Tool Integration: Demonstrated how the CRM integrates with existing marketing tools, using actual data for hands-on practice.
• Gamification Elements: Implemented a points system to incentivize training completion and proficiency.

Results Achieved

Two months post-launch of the custom training, ABC observed remarkable changes:

• Sales Productivity Recovery: Productivity surged by 18%, more than regaining prior levels.
• Support Ticket Decline: CRM-related support requests dropped by 60%, allowing focus on more intricate issues.
• Improved User Satisfaction: Internal surveys revealed an 85% satisfaction rate regarding the new training’s relevance.
• Increased CRM Feature Adoption: The embrace of advanced CRM features— essential for forecasting— climbed by 45%.

Key Use Cases

The custom training included a module focused on ABC’s lead scoring system within the CRM, which helped sales reps prioritize leads based on specific criteria, achieving a 10% rise in lead conversion rates.

An additional module facilitated inter-departmental collaboration, leading to a 15% faster follow-up on marketing-qualified leads.

ABC’s experience underscores the vital difference between rote knowledge transfer and the adept application of skills in a specific organizational context. While the allure of off-the-shelf training was the speed and cost, the substantial long-term benefits from custom training on productivity and employee satisfaction proved far superior.

Conclusion: Future-Proofing Learning Approaches

The shift towards custom training solutions, powered by personalized and immersive learning methodologies, enhances engagement and real-world applicability. While off-the-shelf courses provide convenience, a blended strategy that incorporates both approaches can elevate training outcomes from foundational knowledge to innovative problem-solving.

Explore More:

EI

EI is an emotionally intelligent learning experience design company that collaborates with clients on their Digital Transformation journey.